Crema Constructions' dispute with Malvern Project Developments concerned a Melbourne project with six separable portions, numerous extension of time (EOT) claims and a substantial liquidated damages claim.
Crema Constructions v Malvern Project Developments [2026] VCAT 49
The contractor had submitted 56 EOT claims; extensions had been granted in relation to nine. The principal claimed approximately $8.7 million in liquidated damages and sought recourse to security.
The Tribunal was considering interlocutory relief. It was not conducting a final assessment of all 56 delay claims. That procedural limit matters: refusing to restrain a security call is not a finding that every EOT assessment was correct, or that the full damages claim is payable.
Six portions, potentially six different paths
On a project with separable portions, a programme can show progress in one area while a different sequence controls another completion date. A delay to a shared trade, access route or commissioning activity might affect more than one portion. A delay to work that has float may affect none of them. The expert must identify the relevant contractual completion obligation before analysing criticality.
"On a project with several completion dates, I want to see which activities controlled each one at the time of the alleged delay. A single project-wide critical path can conceal important differences," says Andrew McKenna of Accura Consulting.
The available programmes are a starting point, not a complete answer. A credible assessment compares the logic and status of contemporaneous updates with progress records, site instructions, access constraints and actual sequencing. It also tests whether changes in logic represent genuine changes in construction methodology or retrospective adjustments to support a claim.
What a notice does, and what the programme proves
Crema also raised questions about the superintendent's assessment obligations. The Tribunal did not accept that missing a contractual deadline for a provisional assessment meant the EOT was automatically approved. The effect of a late assessment depended on the contract actually agreed.
An EOT submission therefore has two distinct tasks. The contractor must meet the contract's notice and substantiation requirements; its programme evidence must then establish the impact on the relevant completion date. One cannot be assumed from the other.
“A notice identifies the event and preserves the contractual position. The programme analysis must then explain how that event affected completion, using records that can be tested.”
For lawyers dealing with multiple disputed EOTs, the useful first exercise is often a claim-by-claim matrix: event, notice, contractual clause, affected portion, contemporary programme, critical activity, alleged days and supporting records. It makes the gaps visible before the dispute becomes a contest between retrospective narratives.
At Accura Consulting, our team of experts work with clients to create a tailored solution to problems. If you have an issue and want expert support, get in touch.
Back to News and Insights
Crema v Malvern examines extension of time claims, separable portions, critical path analysis and liquidated damages, with insights for construction lawyers instructing a delay expert witness.